Where to Drink Natural Wine in Williamsburg

Photo via @rudemouthbk

Williamsburg has long been one of New York City’s best neighborhoods for natural wine. From intimate spots pouring small-production wines from across Europe to lively backyard bars and late-night dance floors, there’s no shortage of places to discover a new favorite bottle.

Whether you’re a seasoned natural wine drinker on the hunt for an interesting pét-nat or just looking for somewhere to share a bottle of orange wine with friends, here are some of the best places to drink natural wine in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.


Photo via @rudemouthbk

Rude Mouth

A relatively recent addition to Williamsburg’s natural wine scene, Rude Mouth grew out of a pop-up started by sisters Ava and Sophie Trilling. Now housed in the former Spuyten Duyvil space, the bar takes an approachable attitude toward low-intervention wine, with an ever-changing selection from small producers and plenty of interesting options by the glass.

The warm wood interiors and leafy backyard make this an easy choice for everything from a first date to a catch-up with a group of friends. There’s also a thoughtful selection of craft beer and cider, plus cheeses, cured meats and other snacks to keep you going between pours.

 

With Others

Opened in 2024 by Shanna Nasiri, With Others is a stylish neighborhood wine bar with more than 250 bottles from small producers. The selection emphasizes low-intervention winemaking, women winemakers and lesser-known wine regions, making it a great place to discover something new.

Bright and airy by day and candlelit by night, With Others is particularly well suited to a date or a leisurely evening over a bottle. A rotating roster of chefs keeps the food offering interesting, and the bar’s Sunday Wine School is worth checking out if you want to learn more about what’s in your glass.

 

Photo via saucedbklyn.com 

Sauced

If you like your natural wine without the ceremony, Sauced is the place to go. Instead of handing you a lengthy wine list, the staff take a conversational approach to helping you choose a wine based on what you enjoy and how adventurous you’re feeling.

With its relaxed interior, music and sprawling backyard, Sauced feels more like a neighborhood party than a traditional wine bar. It’s a particularly good choice if you’re looking for somewhere to start the evening with a bottle and end up staying well into the night.

 

BABA

Tucked away on Withers Street, BABA is a French- and Mediterranean-inspired natural wine bar with an equally strong appreciation for good food and good company. Its drinks menu brings together natural wines and cocktails, while the kitchen serves shareable dishes with Mediterranean influences.

The lively, convivial atmosphere makes it a great pick for a group of friends who want to order a few plates for the table and work their way through a bottle or two. There’s also outdoor seating for warmer evenings, and a happy hour worth keeping an eye on.

 

Photo via fourhorsemenbk.com 

The Four Horsemen

Few places have done as much to put Williamsburg on the natural wine map as The Four Horsemen. Co-founded by LCD Soundsystem’s James Murphy, the Grand Street institution has earned both a Michelin star and a James Beard Award for its wine program. Its extensive list is a particular draw for lovers of independent European growers.

Despite its accolades, the dining room is intimate and understated, with warm wood tones and a neighborhood feel. The ever-evolving menu of seasonal small plates makes this as much a destination for dinner as for wine. Reservations can be hard to come by, so plan ahead or try your luck at the bar.

 

Photo via pdvnyc.com

Plus de Vin

Located near the Greenpoint border, Plus de Vin (or PdV) is a neighborhood wine bar with a remarkably deep cellar. Its collection of more than 500 bottles leans toward France, with particularly interesting options from Burgundy and Champagne and an emphasis on thoughtful farming and low-intervention winemaking.

The laid-back space and covered backyard are ideal for settling in with friends over a bottle and a few snacks. For anyone curious to broaden their palate, the bar has also offered Tuesday flight nights featuring blind pours selected by the team.

 

Have & Meyer

Part natural wine bar, part Italian restaurant, Have & Meyer brings the spirit of an Italian vineria to Havemeyer Street. Its extensive collection celebrates independent winegrowers, with particular strengths in skin-contact wines and older vintages. The impressive by-the-glass offering lets you explore different styles without committing to a whole bottle.

The rustic interior, shelves lined with wine and intimate lighting make this one of the neighborhood’s more romantic options. Pair your wine with Italian dishes made with seasonal ingredients, or settle in for dinner if you’re in the mood for something more substantial than the usual wine bar snacks.

 

Pinkerton

Established in 2010, Pinkerton is one of Williamsburg’s original neighborhood wine bars. Its rotating glass-pour list combines traditional wines with natural reds, orange wines and pét-nats, making it a great place to introduce a more traditionally minded wine drinker to something different.

Its cozy vintage interior and corner sidewalk patio give it the feel of a genuine neighborhood local. Order some oysters, cheese or charcuterie to go with your wine and settle in for a low-key evening away from the busier stretches of Bedford Avenue.

 

Photo via honeys.nyc 

Honey’s

Over in industrial East Williamsburg (bordering on Bushwick), Honey’s brings together a bar, experimental winery and creative event space. Its rotating natural wine selection is curated by its in-house winemaker, and the drinks program also includes inventive cocktails and house-produced fermented beverages.

What sets Honey’s apart is its programming. The space hosts everything from chef pop-ups and screenings to late-night dance parties, and its rooftop opens during warmer months. If you’re looking for natural wine in a setting tied to Brooklyn’s music and arts scene, this is a particularly good one to know about.

 

Nightmoves

From the team behind The Four Horsemen, Nightmoves is a small dance bar that brings together natural wine, cocktails and music. Its intimate, sound-focused space and vinyl DJ sets make it a very different experience from its acclaimed neighbor, though the appreciation for independent producers carries over to the drinks menu.

Come here when you want a night that’s more about dancing than sitting around discussing tasting notes. Alongside creative cocktails and independent spirits, you’ll find natural wines that make Nightmoves a fun alternative to the neighborhood’s more conventional late-night bars. The small space can fill up quickly.

Note: Can be hard to get in if you don’t know someone who can put you on the guest list.

 

More Williamsburg Spots for Natural Wine

Not every great natural wine destination is a wine bar. These three Williamsburg favorites are worth adding to your list, too.

 

Hotel Delmano

Known for its beautifully weathered, old-world interior and excellent cocktails, Hotel Delmano also has a wine list focused on small artisanal producers, including several natural wine pours by the glass. The wine selection isn’t exclusively natural, but it’s worth exploring alongside oysters, seafood and small plates.

 

Deux Chats

This South Williamsburg cocktail bar pairs an elegant, vintage-inspired setting with martinis, oysters and wines. Look out for orange wines and chilled reds on Deux Chats’ drink menu if you want the energy of a cocktail bar rather than a dedicated wine destination. Check the current menu for available pours.

 

Leo

From the team behind Bushwick’s Ops, Leo is a neighborhood pizza restaurant where natural wine is every bit as much a part of the experience as the sourdough pies. It’s an easy choice for a casual dinner with friends, especially if your idea of a perfect pairing is a good pizza and a bottle from an independent winemaker.

 

Open bar tabs from your phone

Julep lets you open a bar tab, close out, and tip directly from your phone with Apple Pay or Google Pay — so you can spend less time waiting around and more time enjoying your night.

Learn more ⇢

 

More in Williamsburg:

 

More in Guides:

Next
Next

Best Dive Bars in Greenpoint, Brooklyn